You Are Not Happy
- 09
- 22
- 09
I hate to break it to you. Especially because I don’t know you. Or, maybe I do. Maybe you are my sister. Or my mother. Or my mother-in-law. Or my friend. Or my neighbor. Or my daughter’s teacher. Or my husband. Or my barista. Or maybe you are me. Then again, you can never really know someone. Even yourself. But that is for another time.
I hate to break it to you, but you aren’t happy. You are a graceful pretender. Your smile is winning. Your facade is architecturally sound and lovely. You spin through your days shedding laughter like a tree does leaves. You have a good job. You have a stellar education. You have a fabulous partner. Your kids are cute and cuddly and creative. Your home is serene. You have your health. You have your wealth. You have so many things.
But still. You are not happy. I don’t need to know you to know this much. Not happy. Sorry.
Wait. I’m not sorry. Not even the slightest bit. Because if I know this about you, you should know this about you.
So. Now you know.
Now it is my turn to explain myself. Why am I bullying my way into your innocent Tuesday morning with this psychological satchel of doom and gloom? Who do I think I am? You are living your life, soaking up the fibers of a new day. You are home with your kids, or at the office settling in, or at the coffee shop waking up. You are doing your thing. And, here I am, interrupting your thing. Not just interrupting your thing, but telling you something you don’t want to hear.
You. Are. Not. Happy.
But this is not doom and gloom, so bear with me. This is truth. And truth is a slimy beast. It wiggles away from the most able hands. It escapes the most pointed minds. It has evaded us all for centuries. But some things, simple things, are undeniably true.
One thing: there is no such thing as perfect happiness.
Happiness is something we all want. We crave it like cookies. It fuels us. To aim bigger. To be bigger. We chase it. We pursue it. We talk about it. Hey, we even take classes about it.
You are not happy because there is no such thing as “happy.” It’s not that from my digital pedestal, I have keen insight into supreme suffering about which you are unaware. No. You are not happy, I am not happy, no one is happy because Happiness (that Platonic-type beast with a capital H) is a destination which we will never reach. A destination, which by its very nature, its exquisite essence, is unreachable.
Do you feel better about things? I hope so. And if you are still a pinch peeved that I have tainted your Tuesday with psychobabble poison, don’t blame me. Blame my wise professor du jour, Tal Ben-Shahar. He said it. He boiled it down. I am but a humble and invigorated messenger. He said that there is no such thing as “happy.” But there is “happier.”
Happiness, like most other heavyweight human concepts, exists along a continuum. And yet. We tend to think in problematic binary opposites. We tend to say we are happy or unhappy. We tend to identify a movie or a book as good or bad. We tend to label a politician as honest or dishonest. And perhaps we are wired to do this. But we are missing something, something big, something true, when we do this.
If I didn’t learn another thing in this Positive Psychology class, it would have been worth it to learn this. To learn that I am not happy!
To learn that when it comes to happiness, we are bartering in glorious grays. This truth is at once humbling and liberating. If we can never be truly, unequivocally happy, if there is no utopia waiting to welcome us, we can relax our expectations. We can breathe.
We can stop fretting about being happy and focus on being happier.
And maybe I am foolish, or riding a timely wave of caffeine-fueled optimism (go Starbucks!), but little things can make us happier. Little things we might have disregarded when our goal was that much grander, when our aim was to attain the unattainable. Little things.
Little things like looking at the picture above. Of two girls tangled. My girls. Little creatures full of my genes and my dreams. Looking at this picture, at the tiny toes and dimpled elbows, the chubby promise, the nascent and palpable love, makes me happier.
Little things like writing a blog post. A blog post about truth and its messy threads. A blog post about that thing we all want, desperately, rabidly, obsessively. About that thing we can never fully have. Writing such a blog post makes me happier because in writing it I admit something to you and to me. Because in writing it, I bow to limits. Because in writing these words, in realizing what they mean, the sharp corners of the world instantly dull, the harsh details blur, the insecurities that abound – in sad eyes and furrowed brows and crossed arms – become inspirations. Suddenly, the islands collide and gulfs disappear.
There is something we all want. And we can’t have it.
We can have bits and pieces of it. We can. But we can never have it all. And we can curse this. We can bemoan the fact that we are constantly striving, toiling, for a prize that can never be won.
OR. We can see this as I am just now beginning to see it. Liberating. Inspiring. We are not supposed to be happy because we cannot possibly be happy and this means that we can stop pretending. We can stop ironing out our existential wrinkles. We can stop flashing faux smiles. We can stop working so hard to convince life’s jury that we are happy. We can stop. And now, finally, we can focus on living. A good life. A happier life. Because that is something each and every one of us can have.
We can’t have it all. But we can have some. And some can be amazing. If we let it be.
_______________________
What is one thing you have done today that has made you happier? Yes, reading this post counts! (If you are stumped and can’t answer this question, something needs to change.)










I wrote a post on my family blog about how last night, for the first time, my 10-month-old son gave me an actual, on-purpose hug.
By the way, the hug was pure magic.
Also, for the record, I’m still stewing on the rest of your post. I’m having a defiant reaction to the idea that I am not, cannot be, happy. I am not yet to the enlightened place of finding that statement liberating. “Happier” just doesn’t seem good enough, right? I want “happy” the whole she-bang. Hmmm. Okay, back to my stewing.
I ran 6 miles outside this morning. I really didn’t want to get out bed before sunrise. Especially because my husband and 5 yo son (who apparently crept in around 5) were sleeping so peacefully. But I made myself get up and I’m so happy I did. On my run, I thought about how the school year is going and how proud I am that the kids adjusted so well. I thought of an idea for my case, a way to handle a tricky situation, and I reminded myself to have my watch battery changed. And I also burned some calories. Pretty good start to a pretty good day.
whoever said we have to be happy… very nicely written -
I’m making a concerted effort these days to not focus on whether something makes me “happy”, but whether it satisfied me in some way—whether I gained something I needed, or made a connection, or learned something new, or understood something in a new way. It can be as simple as taking a nap or a walk, having lunch with a coworker, acknowledging whether or not a book—or a TV show, movie, play, friend—is worth my time, and if not, having the courage to step away from it without feeling guilty. Knowing that my attention was well spent, according to what I value (which is different for everybody): that’s what satisfies me.
Okay, so it’s been approximately nine years since we last had this conversation…but now having a little more life under my belt, I still maintain my position.
To me, happiness is still the absence of pain, and therefore at the moment I am happy (other than the tinge of a headache from working too much today). The point is that it is attainable because you’re trying to get to a point of zero or a lack of something….rather than getting a something of which you can never have enough. I think I get the same sense of liberation and freedom, from this realization as you do from your realization that you’re not happy. But here’s the thing…if you start thinking about the things that make you happier, then you’re always going to want more of them, and you’ll get sad when those things (like an amazing conversation, or a perfect vacation, an inspiring run or delicious meal) end, or go away…and when you’re worried about these things ending, or going away, or how to get more of them, you’re not really enjoying them anymore, and you’re not happy.
Oh dear….I think I may have explained that better last time under the influence of some pinot on a thursday night! But I still love having this conversation with you.
And here I was on the way to work thinking I am so happy, but you know, now I am thinking I was happier because I got up and worked out and happier still because I stopped and got a Pumpkin Spice latte, which made me happier still because I love when it is time for that flavor.
Thanks for the perspective, something to really think about.
You are absolutely correct, I am not happy, I’m not sure I’ve ever really thought I was truly and completely happy. But then again I am generally a depressed pessimist, so it’s not surprising! I’m just not sure what I’m going to do about making myself happier yet.
Is it that we aren’t happy, or is it that it’s an unrealistic expectation to think you’ll be actively joyous every or most moments in your life, no matter how content and fulfilled you are?
I remembered that I had some homemade, gluten free, chocolate cake in the freezer. Yum.
A happiness spectrum, I like that. I really like that.
I think one can be really “Happy.” Of course, it depends how you define it. To me, Happiness is not absolute nirvana, but instead a feeling of fulfillment, satisfaction and joy that permeates the day. Every second of my day is not spent in ecstatic bliss, true, but I honestly do feel “Happy” (gods, please don’t smite me). To me, thinking too long about whether I am Happy can only make things worse, tearing down positive feelings as opposed to enjoying each moment as it comes and moving on. Which means that my “Happy” day is probably the same as your “happier” day, but I just don’t dwell on it or turn it over in my mind. Not saying it is better or worse, just different I guess. And DBP, I still think Happiness is the presence of joy in various forms, as opposed to the absence of pain (because bland without joy doesn’t equal Happy for me), but then I just maintain my position from years past too. In either definition, whether it is zero pain or total perfect bliss, I think striving for an absolute is the problem. To me, Happiness does not equal being perfectly “Happy” all the time, it is more relaxed than that. Maybe I am just lazily Happy, but that works for me
.
Thanks for inviting us to peel back the veneer, name what’s true, and then live, live, live – truly, authentically, calling things as they are, and allowing ourselves to feel (and acknowledge) what we feel. My theory: when we can do that…even if it’s painful, messy, excruciating stuff…we’re closer to “happiness” than ever before (though I don’t think that’s really the goal).
Your post makes me happy.
No veneer. Just truth.
Hmmm that’s something to chew on. I completely agree we are all chasing a pie in the sky that does not exist. I also feel our generation has gotten out of hand with our sense of entitlement. Happiness being one of those things people feel entitled to. You have to work on being happy, its not just going to knock on your door, and invite itself in. Well written, and thank you for the wonderful comment you left me.