In-Laws or Outlaws?
- 03
- 19
- 10

I met Husband’s parents very soon after Husband and I started dating. About two months or so. They came to town one weekend for dinner and a show. Frankly, I was all of twenty-three, super naive, and in a bit of a lovey-dovey haze, so I didn’t get too nervous. I was actually excited.
But.
But the night before they arrived, I found myself vomiting – and violently – and camped out on my bathroom tiles. Lovely. I was not just ill. I was ill. Turns out I had a bout of the Norwalk Virus that was spiraling through my good city. But I rallied. And by the time the in-laws swooped into town, I was able to transfer from horizontal to vertical, shower and dress. Husband and I headed to the restaurant to meet them.
And there they were. The most put-together, attractive set of parents I’ve ever seen (next to my own, bien sur). And I was mildly intimidated by these polite and pretty creatures especially because – barely in the wake of my stomach bug – I felt like a mere shell of myself and could barely string a sentence together. It was not the best moment in which to meet the People to Impress.
But anyway.
Dinner was lovely. I sipped slowly from my water glass and barely touched my wine. I picked at my food. This was nothing like me and I sat there thinking, I am acting like the opposite of me. Normally, I would be savoring the courses and the conversations. But not that night. But I held it together. I smiled at appropriate intervals. I felt safe sitting next to Husband. I made it through the evening without a vomit incident in an upscale restaurant. I considered it a victory.
So, looking back, I did not make the best first impression. But thankfully I’ve had a few years to make up for it. As I learned long ago, Grammy and Dad-Dad are not just lookers, but they are warm, intelligent, and loving. When it comes to the In-Law Lottery, I unwittingly hit the Jackpot. I consider myself lucky. Very.
At this point in my life, a good number of my friends are married. And you know what? Many of them have problematic relationships with their in-laws. Many of them. Over the years, I have heard tons of shocking and hilarious and wacky in-law sagas. I am beginning to realize – and thank my lucky stars – that in this arena, I seem to be the exception to the Have-In-Laws-Have-Issues-Rule.
It’s funny because my Mommy Friends have been passing around an advance copy of LIFE AFTER YES. I am thrilled to say that they have all loved it. But recently one of these friends emailed to say that she adored the story, but she had one question.
Did your mother-in-law read it yet??!!
At this question, I smiled. Because there is a difficult mother-in-law character in my story. One that is not even marginally based on Grammy. For those of you who are writers, this might prove an interesting aside, but when I signed with Agent, she had a few insightful comments on my manuscript. In her estimation, the protagonist’s beau Sage was too good, too squeaky-clean. Agent suggested I dirty him up a bit so he would better balance his exceptionally-flawed amour. And so I did. I added a new character to the mix. His mother. A domineering and depressed Mama Bear who has trouble releasing her claws. This additional fifty pages brought the book to a whole new level of intrigue and depth. Point is that I have a good agent and that there is zero connection between my fictional and my real MIL.
Anyway, this is all a very, very roundabout way of telling you that we are all headed to Pennsylvania later today to visit Grammy and Dad-Dad for the weekend to celebrate Dad-Dad’s impending sixty-fifth birthday. And we are excited. Not for the near-certainty of car vomit, but for the change of pace and scenery and for the good dose of family fun.
And I sit here, moments before the girls rise, contemplating the day ahead, the many things I must do before we hit the road. There is a Preschool breakfast, and a construction meeting, and an appointment in midtown. There is wine to order. There are bags to pack. And it is all kind of overwhelming. Particularly because I’m not moving at full speed this morning and these days – emotionally at least.
You see, Monday would be my own Dad’s sixty-eighth birthday if he were still around and I tend to fall apart around this time of the year. This time last year was a rough and revealing stretch for me. A time when I stopped pretending I was totally okay and began to let myself examine my life after loss. A time when it occurred to me to start a blog. To open up. To acknowledge struggle. Mine. All of ours. To ask questions. Mine. All of ours. It was an impossible time for me, but ultimately an exquisite turning point. I’m able to see this now.
But this year. I am a bit better. A lot better, actually. Just heavy with awareness and soft with sadness as I anticipate Monday and think about that gaping hole in my family’s fabric.
But this year. I am able to see the life-honed bounty at my feet. I am able to see the simple and stunning truth that I am alive, awash in a sea of family – by blood, by law, by life, and, yes, by blog – that buoys me through the good days.
And the harder ones.
_______________________________
- Am I the only one who genuinely loves my in-laws? Do you have In-Law Issues? (Has anything exacerbated these issues? Kids? Incidents? Confrontations? Geographical distance?)
- Tell me your best (a.k.a. worst) in-law story!
- Tell me your “Met the Parents” story!
- Have you ever broken up with someone you cared about because his/her parents were terrible?
- Have you ever imagined how you will be as someone else’s in-law?
- Are there particular times of year when you tend to have a hard time for one reason or another?
- In retrospect, did you start your blog for a reason, a deeper reason, than you once thought?











My in-laws are great. I would not say that I am close to them but they are nice people, my father-in-law in particular. He is a daily reminder to be grateful for those things we take for granted, namely health, because he had a heart transplant seven years ago and the fact of that still takes my breath away. Someone else’s heart beats in his chest. Imagine that? It’s a miracle, plain and simple.
I am sorry for the Monday anniversary. I can imagine that is very, very difficult. I’m glad that this bloggy wonderland came out of that sad time, though, and think that shows both resilience and creativity on your party. My opinion is that you write luminously and lovingly of your father, and so ILI is in some ways a testament to him. And a way of honoring him. I still love that quote he loved (that of course I can’t remember exactly) about straight and not-straight sticks? Maybe I should give up the Splenda too … eeek.
See you soon!
xo
Our friend L. started my blog for me in the lobby of UCLA Hospital, as my daughter lay upstairs fighting for her life. I didn’t know what a blog was. I thought it was a way to connect with loved ones who were desperate to know what was going on.
But, yes, to answer your last question, it turns out that the continued blogging has sprung from a well of deeper reasons…not least of which is the desire to share the joy and pain of human existence. “We blog to know we’re not alone?”
And you, most, definitely, are not alone.
I ache for you in the loss of your father at such a young age. I know you must be sad that he will not get to be a part of your children’s lives. I am so sorry for your family’s loss. But I want to encourage you to allow yourself the privilege of grieving for as long as you need to. Coincidentally, I am working on a post on that now. I feel that we don’t give ourselves permission to process loss in healthy ways in this culture. Grieving is a process…and we should allow it to run its necessary course.
I lost my father 7 years ago. I still miss him. But just this week, I finally had another bit of closure. I called it “Holding On While Letting Go.” (http://kimarnoldblog.blogspot.com/2010/03/holding-on-while-letting-go.html)
It will get easier.
I love my in-laws, especially my mother-in-law. She is laid back, accepting, supportive, affectionate (without smothering) and the rock of her entire family. She has three daughters, so she has never tried to make me her own in any way. And since the beginning we’ve had a lovely (if difficult to describe) relationship that is half friendship and half parental. I treasure it.
I hope that you have a wonderful time in PA. And I hope that being enveloped in family for a couple of days will help bolster you against Monday’s looming presence. Your dad lives on through your words here, which is a testament to the great man he clearly was during his life. Safe travels!
No, you are not the only ones. I adore my in-laws. They are generous, non-judgmental, easy going, and are truly good people. They raised 3 very compassionate adults and raised a son whose many admirable qualities (besides being dashing and handsome) were (partly) fashioned out of their good parenting.
Aidan, I don’t know you or your family, but your father seems like he was a true gem. I am very sorry–I cannot imagine going through this. Says the daughter of another sportsman, conservationist (and South Carolinian).
*HUGS* to you, my friend… this weekend and into next week. you will be in my thoughts.
I love this post. In my former life, I loathed all things related to in-laws. What exacerbated those issues? Maybe a 30something who was more in love with his mom and dad than his fiance?
Then I was sure I had won the in-law jackpot (as I have none!) when I married my husband, but missing 2 grandparents means there is a hole in our family’s fabric, too.
Aid, thinking of all of you on Monday…
xoxo
Enjoy your trip to my state of residence — the weather Saturday is supposed to be gorgeous!! Again, I don’t have time to respond substantively, but I hope to soon!
What is is with blogs making me teary this morning? It must be something in the air…
This post moved me because I, too, often fall apart around this time of year. April 3 would be my father’s 62nd birthday, if he hadn’t died in 2006. It still feels like yesterday, but at the same time, it does get easier every year, as you so eloquently point out.
As for in-laws (and fathers passing, actually) my father-in-law died one week after our wedding. He got sick exactly one month before our wedding… damn pancreatic cancer and it’s crazy speed. I think these events have given both me and my husband very special MIL relationships. We are protective of them. While most of my friends see their MILs as predators, to us they are delicate… new to a world of loneliness that we want to shield them from. But now we are all bonded by a common loss.. which I think sadly brings us closer.
This brought tears into my eyes! My grandmother passed away 8 years this June 24 days after my son was born! She was my favorite person in the world!! To this day, not only her death anniversary or her birthday are sad days for me, but anytime I think or talk about her I feel miserable…I should get over it, maybe one day!
As for MIL horror stories I have lots! Actually one related to my grandmother: when my son was born we were still living with my MIL. One Friday morning my cell rang, and after that I was screaming in my room: my sister was telling me about my grandmother’s passing. My MIL came running to my room, opened the door and said: waht happened to my grandson? I replied in tears, my son in my arms, nothing to him but my grandmother died! and she replied: oh thank god for that! You scared me I thought you dropped the kid…
Good luck on Monday. I will be sending good thoughts your way!
We never get over losing parents, do we? I’m sorry for your sadness with your father.
But so glad you were lucky in the in-law department. I’m more at the stage now where I’m anticipating the amazing mother-in-law I might be.
Enjoy your visit!
My husband’s parents are long divorced and both happily remarried. And I am lucky enough to have two fabulous mothers-in-law. While they are very different, they are both kind, considerate, and generous. I enjoy spending time with them and feel welcome in their homes. I think it helps that I am the only hope for grandkids. It’s me or nothing, which adds some pressure, but also gives the moms-in-law a larger context to think about.
My husband’s mom taught me how to knit and regularly takes me yarn shopping. It’s been a really nice bonding activity and it’s introduced me to my librarian required hobby. His step mom is just really thoughtful. When we got married, she framed our invitation for us, which was a really sweet gift. I’ve copied that move when I’ve been in weddings and it’s been a winner every time.
On the other hand, my mom is the humdinger in the family. She drives my husband batty, is demanding, and wears us out. She constantly lays on the pressure about babies, forgets that we are hard-working professionals and that my husband only has two weeks of vacation a year. We’ve had to have some talks about boundaries and expectations. We’re hoping that she will calm down but it’s taking awhile.
My in laws are pretty good, we don’t really have any big issues. My MIL and I had a bit of an problem the first year we were married but set down like grown ups and talked about it and it’s been fine ever since. My husband has a harder time with my parents than I do with his, mostly because mine are a bit more controlling.
Also-thoughts, prayers and big hugs to you regarding your father and the pain that must resurface constantly without warning. I’m so sorry that you are hurting.
I never broke up with someone b/c their were awful but I stayed with my HS (junior/senior year) boyfriend because I loved his parents and they loved me. And Senior year, on our way up with his parents to see Cornell, he broke up with me at the rest stop. And I was stuck for the weekend and I didn’t have the heart to tell his mom, who I was sharing a room with for two nights. So I endured, through dinner and “Fatal Attraction,” the hot movie that had opened that weekend that the four of us went to go see! It was an awkward and early lesson in dating and staying with the person for who they are and not how much you love (or hate) their family!
My dad died suddenly 14 years ago and his 72nd birthday would have been this past Sunday, so I know what you are going through. I still miss him terribly but I do take comfort in the vestiges of him I see peeking out in looks, mannerisms and personality of my children, the closest thing to immortality I have encountered.
As for my inlaws, my mother in law was wonderful, not perfect but an amazing warm lady who also died too young, when my daughter was 14 months old. My father in law is okay, though somewhat distant, in geography and personality. I didn’t win the jackpot as you did but it could be a lot worse!
Sadness and joy are so often woven together in our lives, as your trip and the anniversary of your dad’s passing so poignantly demonstrates. I lost my grandfather the day I found out I was pregnant with my daughter. In some ways, that circle of life is comforting; in other ways, it’s excruciating. I’m hoping you have a restful weekend and come home with renewed strength for the tough Monday ahead.
My MIL was nice, but quiet, subservient – pretty much the opposite of me. We got along alright, but saw each other rarely. She passed 10 years ago and my honey was very sad. His dad, my FIL, just passed in December. We never got along, but then, he never really got along with anyone.
My honey and I are both close to my parents who are, thankfully, still alive, (73 & 69) but live 1,000 miles away in Denver. We travel there often.
I will be sending you soft prayers on Monday. And remember, if you have a spare minute while in PA, give me a call.
That’s why I’m absolutely terrified to show any fiction I write to my friends and family — I know that my characters and plots are completely made up; I may consciously or unconsciously borrow a few details (last year, when writing a story for school, I threw in a bunch of inside-jokes with my boyfriend just for fun, because he’s from Texas and the story took place there), but I’m certainly not trying to portray anyone I know or work through my own issues and relationships with my words. But then I pass the story off to my mom and have a mini-breakdown while she reads, thinking “Oh God, I made the main character’s mom such a b*tch, will she think that’s how I see her?”
As for in-laws, one of the things I never really considered before I met my boyfriend’s parents was that not only will my eventual future husband become part of *my* family, but I’ll also become part of *his.* I’m still sort of adjusting to that idea. It’s weird, but in a good way. I think.
Let’s see…My MIL encouraged my first son to call him “mama” when I was at work… She stormed out moments before his fourth birthday party because she and I got in an argument.. She tells her other son and wife that she likes our kids better than theirs.. She takes the baby right out of the hands of my friends and tries to keep him away from me, even though he always reaches for me… She clearly likes boys better than girls so isn’t as warm to my daughter..
Need I go on?
Sounds like you hit the lottery for sure!
My father died three years ago this summer, and while it does get better, it never goes away. Which it shouldn’t.
Thinking of you..
I too have great in-laws. They love and support me just the way I am. But boy do I have some stories. I have, btw, mined more than a few for my comedy gigs. They always get the biggest/longest laughs.
Thank you for opening yourself – the only way is through.
Again, sending thoughts your way.
I’m sorry about the unhappy anniversary. Have a wonderful trip and eat lots of birthday cake. It may not help, but it most certainly will not hurt.
It’s so amazing that you can feel so grateful for your in-laws in the face of your father’s absence — both a testament to how great they must be, and how great YOU must be.
I will be thinking of you early next week. I am glad you will have so much love surrounding you over the weekend! I have amazing, generous, loving, sweet inlaws… but with all that comes the not so great which I try to shake off because of the positives. I do feel lucky though… luckier than most of my friends to have been handed what I did with them!
For the most part I love my inlaws… they’re quiet people, very quiet. And that, I don’t know exactly what to do with at times. They never talk about emotions, but they love like you wouldn’t believe. However, they’re just a little oblivious to social and emotional cues… ha!
Will be thinking of you this weekend and next week. Glad you’ll be keeping busy
Ah, the in law stories I could tell. Sometimes, I seriously think they are just stories but then I remember I lived those stories.
Aidan, I will keep your whole family in my thoughts and prayers this weekend. Keep busy and write to us all on Monday about your father. It helps. Trust me!
Here’s hoping that you have a wonderful spring weekend with your prize-winning in-laws. I will be thinking of you on Monday.
As for the question of my own in-laws, I plead the Fifth.
Aidan, I’m so sorry about the loss of your father. In some ways I feel like I’m still reeling from the loss of my own, and it was 35 years ago. But I will never forget the day I walked in my house and my sister walked up to me and said, “Dad died.”
I don’t have any in-laws because my husband’s mother died when he was 10 and his father when he was 27. I do have 2 somewhat troublesome sisters-in-law but I’m sure they do they best they can.
I had in-laws in my ex-marriage that I would’ve kept if I could have, and boyfriends’ mothers whom I would have married if I could have taken them and left the guys!
Hope this next week is full of the family you do have, and lots of joy. I can’t imagine losing a parent young, like you did.
And this morning, as I sit here with an injured heart after another argument with my husband about my horrible in-laws, I’m gonna tell you how lucky you are.
I think I just posted a half-finished comment, sorry.
Yesterday was my dad’s bday and our first chance to have his bday without him. I planned my boys’ party on his bday in an attempt, as you said, to appreciate the “bounty” before me. I did and you have to but it was still his day.
Today, we are having lunch with my in-laws. I think some of the issues with in-laws are that people parent and grandparent in different ways. No matter how nice in-laws are, you can’t help but detect differences. My children slept over at my mom’s house last night. She loved it, they loved it. They slept in the space my dad left and my mom slept (or didn’t sleep so much) next to them. My in-laws never have the boys to sleep over. My in-laws are fine seeing the boys on holidays. The differences used to and at times still drive me crazy. However, there is bounty there, and I have to see this too.
If I can accept a loving, devoted parent no longer here. I can accept the in-laws too.
I get along with my in-laws, most of the time… but my husband has issues with his parents, which in return, put a strain on our relationship with his parents.
His parents love and adore me – sometimes I think because they do because that makes them less responsible for making up with their son.
I am very, very close to my own parents/family and it bothers me to no end that my husband’s family isn’t as close. I always try to be the mediator and it still doesn’t work.
Since I am living 6000 miles away from my own family, I wish we were closer with my husband’s family (who only live 500 miles away)… but that’s not the case. It makes me feel very alone sometimes.
I’ve always felt very fortunate with my in-laws. We get along nicely… so many people don’t seem to have that.
As for starting to blog – I think I just started because I’m a chatterbox with a lot to rattle on about. What keeps me going is a different story, one which is all about community and friendships forged across the miles.
How seredipitous..! I just wrote a post about how tough it can be when the grandparents are fully involved in the raising of your kids, and one of the commenters (Kitchen Witch) referred to them as “outlaws” and I thought that was, oh, so clever!
My in laws are pretty good, but there is definitely some dysfunction and tension there.
My mother in law doesn’t “get” me, I don’t think. Then again, I don’t think I’ve allowed her to, either.
Anyways, I’m a bit of glamour girl…stiletto lover, make up fiend, fashion addict. What did she give me for Christmas last year??? Tupperware and kitchen towels.
That says it all.
My dad died 13 years ago and I still miss him. My sympathies on your loss.
My outlaws. Oy. Two weeks before the wedding, they got mad at something I had written in my blog and told my husband they weren’t coming to the wedding and he shouldn’t marry me. It took him a week to convince them to come (I was fine with their not being there) and he finally had to tell them I was pregnant and if they ever wanted to see their grandchild, they would show up for the wedding.
Then I had a miscarriage while they were staying with us.
They are not my favorite people. I am working on a book. If I do publish it, it will have to be under a pseudonym because my book will be exactly about my outlaws and the horrors they have brought into my life. Well, not horrors, but definitely material. (Doesn’t everyone want a framed photo of their inlaws as a Christmas present after they have spent $500 on plane tickets to visit them and do all their household chores?)
My inlaws are great in their own way. They don’t watch the children or help out with our daily lives, but they also don’t meddle or judge. My mother, on the other hand, helps out tremendously (when she can considering she works 2 jobs) but lays the judgment and meddling on thick.
I’m so sorry for the loss of your dad. I can’t imagine how difficult that must be.
I only have one in-law, as my husband’s father died a couple years before I met him (15 years ago), and overall things are pretty good. We’ve had our issues and she has struggled with a nervous breakdown and pretty major depression, but the important stuff is there. She is a fantastic grandmother, very helpful, never bossy or telling me what to do or how to raise my kids. She spends lots of time with my three kids and genuinely loves them dearly. So, overall . . . pretty darn good!
I hope your weekend was fantastic!
My blog has posts dedicated to my grandfather, a dear friend and my dog all of whom I still miss. It has been a tremendous outlet and a place that has given me more than I can possibly say.
As for in-laws, well I have a love/hate thing with mine but that is all I will say here.
My in-laws are gone now, and I miss them, but I feel their spirits and send good wishes that you’ll feel your dad’s love and pride in you on his birthday. My dad’s 84th was St. Patrick’s Day and I’m blessed to still have him… since it’s taken this long to get to a better place with him. He and my mom are not the easiest in-laws… they can get you puking even when nothing’s rotten in Norwalk.
Namaste
My husband is my high school sweetheart, so I met my in-laws when I was only 15. I didn’t feel intimidated by them at all, but I actually think I had a better relationship with them then than I do now. Perhaps it was because I was working so hard to impress. Either way, you should feel incredibly blessed to feel like your in-laws are family. I cannot identify with that feeling at all. I’ve never felt like a member of the family, valued or loved in any way by my in-laws. I don’t think that’s intentional on their part, I just think they see family different than what I’m used to.
I hope your visit is/was wonderful!
My inlaws are the most supportive and genuine people. I was terrified to meet them, but it was within a few minutes that I realized that they were just as worried as I was.
In fact, after a few Sunday dinners and holidays (I live in a different country than my family), I realised that I liked them more than my own family, which was the really scary part.